The Importance of Making Up Your Mind Based On Proofs and Not Merely on AssertionsSomervell County Salon-Glen Rose, Rainbow, Nemo, Glass....Texas


Salon is now an archive. New site here
This site's archives
 
Just because somebody SAYS something is 1 doesn't MAKE it 1
The Importance of Making Up Your Mind Based On Proofs and Not Merely on Assertions
 


30 April 2015 at 7:06:09 PM
salon

And, as I start this, that goes for me too. I am decidedly opinionated and there's no reason for anyone to necessarily believe me if I don't have, say, video or audio or a link to a document to back up what I say. I've noticed lately a rash of assertions about various political issues that merely put forth a premise but without anything at all to back up those assertions. When that happens, I like to think that people will be energized enough to push back and say "Give me examples" or "Why are you saying that, what proof do you have", rather than just believing what very likely is bullchit. 

This is a logical reasoning fallacy entitled Proof by assertion or otherwise known as rhetoric

Argument by assertion is the logical fallacy where someone tries to argue a point by merely asserting that it is 1, regardless of contradiction. While this may seem stupid, it's actually an easy trap to fall into and is quite common.

Rhetoric

It is also well known as rhetoric, because an assertion itself isn't really a proof of anything, or even a real argument - assertion only demonstrates that the person making the statement believes in it. An inability to provide anything other than an argument by assertion may be the result of brainwashing, basing ones belief on blind faith or ignorance as to what forms a proper argument. Those who argue by assertion often do think that they're making a real argument. They might simply not realise where they haven't provided a full argument. The point of constructive debate or discourse is to draw attention to this sort of thing, and for people to further develop and evolve their arguments in response. A truly fallacious argument by assertion is when someone continues to assert without advancing their argument, even after it has been pointed out.

A repeated argument by assertion can also take the form of non sequitur that requires little effort to make and is therefore often used to fatigue people who make actual arguments - sometimes combined with the infamous Gish Gallop. They will then bow out of the debate, usually exhausted, having lost faith in humanity and muttering "how the hell do you reason with these people?!?!" through grinding teeth - at which point the individual making the assertive argument simply declares victory.

 

 

Permalink Tags:          
     Views: 2526 
Latest Blog Post by salon -Video- Somervell County Commissioners Court Special Sessions (2) Dec 23 2019
More Posts You Might Enjoy
Been Wondering- WHY didn't Somervell County Attorney Andrew Lucas have a contract with outside attorney Mackenzie
Sheriff Logs, Jail Logs, Fire Logs from Nov 15, 2019 through Dec 18, 2019
Somervell County Hospital District CFO Report from Dec 5 2019 and I-35 Clinic Info
Why Didn't County Attorney Andy Lucas Keep Extensive Lawsuit Materials in his file?? re: State of Texas ex rel Best v Harper
Somervell County Salon Blog is now an archive site. Commenting not enabled.

Click Here for Main Page



Guest
Today Is  
Tuesday, December 16, 2025






Latest Posts

More Blog Headlines