Home | News | Glen Rose News| Crime | Calendar | Audio/Video | Search
Write!  |profile | quotes | piazza | top Daily | top Weekly | top Month | archives| subscribe RSS
You are logged in as a guest. Logon   | Register

Click Here for Main Page

Education is not the filling of a bucket but the starting of a fire- W B Yeats
- (Added by: salon)

Hot Commented
             Topics

 1  Gov. Rick Perry and his Insurance Industry 'Axis of Evil' (10)
 2  It's 7:30 pm Saturday Night- Where are the Lifeguards? (8)
 3  Video -On Double Standards, Roberts Rules of Order and Darrell Webb/Dwain Whitfield's Disciplinary Hearings (7)
 4  Texas Governor Rick Perry is a Scoundrel, Liar and Coward (7)
 5  Textbooks in Texas for Public School Students? Who Needs Those? TEA Doesn't Think So (6)
 6  Summer Help at The City of Glen Rose-Two Were Children of Regular Employees (Sept 2010) (5)
 7  Where's the Accounting System at Oakdale Park at Glen Rose? (4)
 8  Labor Day Speeches 2010 (4)
 9  Cindy King's Disciplinary Records (September 2010) (4)
 10  something needs to be done (3)
 11  The Khan Academy (3)
 12  Listen to what this Valedictorian has to say (3)
 13  THE PARTY OF NO (2)
 14  Movie and Television Watching Paradigm Shift (Sept 2010) (2)
 15  I-See-You-Naked-TSA-Strip-Searches- Excellent Commentary (2)
 16  Now That We Destroyed Iraq, Let's Leave It (2)
 17  Video-City of Glen Rose Doesn't Get Swimming Pool Grant for Oakdale Park (1)
 18  What it means to me. UPDATE (1)
 19  Alms for the Rich and Powerful, Editorial, NY Times (1)
 20  Audio and Some Pics from the GREDC/4b Meeting Glen Rose Sept 7 2010 (1)
 21  Perry's Bogus Promises (1)
 
Hmm. Questions about the legality of Birdwell's residency, due to one party judicial declaration.
 

from the Waco Trib

On April 20, Birdwell petitioned the Hood County District Court to issue what’s called a declaratory judgment, but in his lawsuit he didn’t name any other parties.

Six days later, Judge William Brigham, a retired appeals court judge assigned to the case, affirmed that Birdwell had been a state resident for the past five years, thus meeting a constitutional requirement for Senate candidates.

But the finding is undermined by the fact that only one party, Birdwell, was named in the case, according to several Baylor University Law School professors and lawyers asked to review it.

Only Birdwell’s attorneys made arguments and submitted evidence to the judge, and potential parties, including Birdwell’s three special election opponents, weren’t notified before the proceedings.

And documents Birdwell’s opponents have argued show he isn’t eligible to run weren’t presented to the court.

I noticed this before myself when I looked, when Birdwell was running against Chet Edwards, at the Hood County appraisal district records. In 2007 he moved to Granbury, Texas and then bought land from some other Birdwell, who I assume is kin. I thought at the time that the Republican party HAD him move to that district in order to try to challenge Edwards. didn't work then. HE DIDN'T MEET THE ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS BECAUSE HE HAD NOT LIVED IN TEXAS FOR TWO YEARS. Guess what, the requirements for Texas Senate are more stringent. Here's Texas Tribune.

In 2007, 9/11 Pentagon attack survivor Brian Birdwell flirted with the idea of a run for the seat occupied by state Rep. Jim Keffer, R-Eastland. It was a non-starter because it turned out he didn’t meet the constitutional requirement of two years of Texas residency preceding the election. Now, he’s filed in the special election to replace state Sen. Kip Averitt, R-Waco, and stands to be undone by the same problem.

The Texas Senate has slightly more rigorous eligibility standards than the lower chamber. According to the Texas Constitution, “No person shall be a Senator, unless he … shall have been a resident of this State five years next preceding his election.” Simple logic would suggest that if Birdwell was unable to adequately demonstrate two years of residency prior to November of 2008, then it will be impossible to establish that he has been living in Texas for five years preceding the May 8 special election.

Now how in the FOOL did he get a judge to say he was eligible? Oh, because he didn't notify his challengers and didn't bring in all the data, hmmmmmmmm? He *seems* like a Christian man, why is he hiding this?

Here's what Hood County appraisal district shows for him as of today. Notice that the property deeds go to 2007.

Hood County Appraisal District information updated 6/17/2010 print this
 page Print Page

Identification

Owner Name: BIRDWELL BRIAN D AND MELVA
Property ID: R000095522
Geographic ID: 17082.000.0012.0
Property Address: CATALINA BAY 1602
Legal Description: Lot: 12, Subd: CATALINA BAY II PHASE ONE
   
Map Number:  

Property Tax Bills

 
Proposed payment date:
(with different proposed payment date)
 
Year Taxing Detail Base Tax Paid Tax Tax Due Additional Fees* Late Fees Amount Due
2009 All applicable taxing entities $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
2008 All applicable taxing entities $18,583.63 $18,583.63 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
2007 All applicable taxing entities $5,859.39 $5,859.39 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
  Total Amount Due:     $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
* Additional Fees include any applicable penalties and interest, attorney and/or late fees.

Ownership/Exemption Information

Name: BIRDWELL BRIAN D AND MELVA Ownership Interest : 1.0000000
Mailing Address: 1602 CATALINA BAY CT
GRANBURY, TX 76049
Exemptions Granted: 100% Disabled Veteran, Disabled Veteran

Property Valuation History

Values by Year   2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 n/a
Improvements + $639,630 $652,680 $673,310 $0 $0 $0
Land + $250,000 $350,000 $300,000 $300,000 $220,000 $0
Production Market + $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Personal + $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Mineral + $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Total Market = $889,630 $1,002,680 $973,310 $300,000 $220,000 $0
Agricultural Loss - $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Homestead Cap Loss - $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Total Assessed = $889,630 $1,002,680 $973,310 $300,000 $220,000 $0

Improvement / Buildings

Improvement Market Value: $652,680  
Group Sequence Code Building Description Year Built Square Footage Perimeter Footage
1 SITE100 SITE IMPROVEMENT 10000 2007 0  
2 ST STORAGE LEV 1 2007 98 42
3 AG GARAGE ATT LEVEL 1 2007 958 134
4 CR COVERED PORCH LEVEL 1 2007 270 94
5 LA LEVEL 1 2007 4,942 398
6 CR COVERED PORCH LEVEL 1 2007 65 36
7 CR COVERED PORCH LEVEL 1 2007 1,040 204
8 POH50 POOL HOUSE 50% 2007 147 52
9 CR COVERED PORCH LEVEL 1 2007 21 20
11 PO15 SWIM POOL 15000 2007 0  
12 BD15 BOAT DOCK 15000 2007 0  
13 FN90 FENCE 9000 2007 0  

Land Details

Land Market Value: $350,000 Production Market Value: $0 Production Value: $0  
Land Code Acres Sq. Ft. Front Ft. Rear Ft. Depth Mkt. Value Prd. Value
250000 0.000 0 0 1   250,000 0

Deed History

Sold By Volume Page Deed Date Instrument
BIRDWELL MELVA LIVING TRUST 2486 0039 6/15/2009  
M W CATALINA LTD 002151 00623 11/10/2005 B-236

Taxing Entities / Jurisdictions

Code Description Taxable Value Tax Rate per $100 Tax
GR GRANBURY CITY 0 0.004039000 $0.00
HOD HOOD COUNTY 0 0.002854310 $0.00
LIB LIBRARY 0 0.000096380 $0.00
LTR LATERAL ROAD 0 0.000360220 $0.00
SGR GRANBURY I.S.D. 0 0.011550000 $0.00
  Total Estimation   0.018899910 $0.00

 

By salon Views: 294
Be The First To Comment



Read More Site Comments
Tags:      
del.icio.us Newsvine  



Comments!    You! Leave a Comment! You Know you Want To!

Name: -Anonymous comments are always moderated
Email: -Required but your email will not show
Comment:
 

Or you can login!

LOGON - Name:Password:

 Not registered?

New poster comments are moderated, meaning they won't show up until approved... or not.  That's whether you post anonymously OR are registered. Be patient-we have lives outside this blog, so it might take awhile  If you want your picture to show up, you must be registered and have gone into your profile to add a pic. You want to be rude? totally stupid? inappropriate? Flame war baiter? Your post may be deleted. Spammers or people posting pretend interest comments but really wanting to hawk their latest book or sell stuff or govt propaganda flacks won't see their posts published. Comments do not necessarily reflect the viewpoint of the site owner.
If you have a problem with logging in or registering, please tell us right away. we love your comments. Oh, except spammers
More on commenting


Stream O News

About John Cornyn:Cornyn condemns decision by U.S. Department of Education
About John Cornyn:Millions allotted for Killeen Airport improvements
About Chet Edwards:Flores cries foul
About Chet Edwards:Flores Threatens Legal Action Over Edwards Political Ad
About Kip Averitt:Averitt likely return to Texas statehouse as lobbyist
About Kip Averitt:Cullar withdraws from senate race
About Kip Averitt:Cullar decides to withdraw
About Kip Averitt:Court nixes appeal of state senator*s eligibility
About Kip Averitt:Court denies residency challenge
About Chet Edwards:Bill Flores says Rep. Chet Edwards* new ad has gone too far
About Chet Edwards:Flores, Edwards trade jabs over campaign TV ads
About Chet Edwards:Flores calls on Edwards to pull *defamatory* layoff ad
Chron-Pol:Woman killed when truck strikes pillar in NW Houston
Think Progress:Daisy Khan Tells TP She And Her Husband Would Prefer Not To Meet Terry Jones On 9/11
Think Progress:Gingrey Promises A ‘God’s Covenant With Moses’ Signed ‘In Blood’ To Extend Bush Tax Cuts For The Wealthy

More News N Blogs