Audio from the Meet the Candidates Glen Rose ISD School Board Night


 

Audio from the Meet the Candidates Glen Rose ISD School Board Night
 


28 April 2009 at 4:48:13 PM
salon

April 27, 2009

MP3 here (best to right click and download to your computer to listen)

and a commentary

I had not been to a “Meet the Candidates” forum for school board candidates before. I am not a fan of the style in which this one was held. Let me say first that I believe that when people want to be elected or reelected, they are the ones to be questioned, to be held up to a vigorous debate in which their choices, their decisions, and their positions on issues that will impact the general public and the school system are to be questioned and expected to be answered, whether satisfactorily or not. The people who we elect to office… yes… elect… are the ones that need to prove they are deserving of the opportunity to serve the public, particularly when they will be responsible for how our taxes our spent, and, in the case of education, how young minds will be educated. For that reason, every single candidate needs to be open to, defend and inform any citizen who asks any question, so that those who may not be the best can be examined and their answers thoughtfully considered. In other words, plenty of respect but no coddling. One of the elements of this event was to have the candidates ask questions of the audience;; while that was nice, was this really a coffee clatch meeting? Having the forum be rather along the lines of “Let’s Meet the Coach with Donuts” with warm fuzzy, pre-scripted questions does not serve the voting public.

The “Meet the Candidates” seating arrangement assumed few people would show up to listen, as the tables used were arranged in a square, rather than a face-off.

Other meetings I have attended at the Citizens Center (and other venues) have the traditional seating of the candidates at the front, perhaps on stage or speaking at a podium, with the audience facing and able to ask questions freely and without restriction. (I use as an example, the excellent Meet the Candidates forum for City officials that was held a year or two ago in the High School auditorium. The moderator was Dr Condi, the candidates sat on the stage, and Dr Condi both asked the questions which were written to each candidate as well as take open questions from the audience. From a technical perspective, having people speak into microphones, both from the stage and with questions, aids immensely with proper sound control.

 
I also was puzzled by the use of writing questions on flip-board white paper.
Before the meeting began, one of the teachers hosting this event solicited questions. The questions were then written on a large piece of paper which was held up before the small audience. Was the intent because people’s failing memories would not allow them to remember the question after it was spoken? I was reminded of conferences I’ve attended before in which those types of charts are used to facilitate brainstorming-but this was not a brainstorming session… or was it intended, rather, to be that?
 
One disturbing element of the event was that the questions were censored if Mr. Rotan did not approve. I was not aware that he was in charge of the event-apparently so. I had seen the art teacher,Randy Haney, solicit questions before the event, writing them down on the flip chart paper, and at least one attendee approach. Then I saw Mr. Rotan go back to the back, and then saw that same attendee conferring with the art teacher. I didn’t think much about it until after the meeting was over, when it came out that the questions were pre-screened and censored, with Mr. Rotan giving ultimate approval over any questions that might, in the opinion of he or the art teacher, be inappropriate.
Also note that the email that went out concerning this forum, from Mr Haney, included no indication that any censorship would go on.

Please remember to make time to attend tonight's Candidates Forum to be held at the Citizens Center just off the square, starting at 5:00 this evening.

The questions and responses in the newspaper were a good start, but please consider attending so that you can ask YOUR questions and hear what the candidates have to say in response, and also to listen to questions the candidates may have for those who attend. Refreshments will be served starting at 5:00 p.m. The discussion will end by 6:45 p.m.

YOUR questions. Unless we don't like them.
I have serious reservations with events in which the questions are staged, censored and pre-screened. President Bush did that quite often with his canned public meetings that not only quite often prevented those with opposing viewpoints from attending but arranged what would be said and who would say it.. all in order to provide a pleasant, faux public relations opportunity rather than be part of a vibrant democratic process. In my view, it is the job of the moderator(s) of the event, not to prevent anyone from asking a question, but stepping in if the question seems inappropriate (or allowing the person questioned to demur) or a person takes too long, or the temperature of the audience becomes too heated, etc. It is *not* the job of the moderator to prevent others from asking questions, any questions they please. But that’s what happened. I find that type of censorship particularly troubling when you consider that these are educators that, one would suppose, are teaching young minds about every person’s participation in democracy.
 
One interesting comment was that people in general are afraid to approach the school board. “I know you’re on the school board but you can’t talk to me”. (Video clip of that comment by Dr Davis followed by the art teacher attempting to make sure that Ogletree's question was in an approved form)
Guess what! By censoring and pre-screening questions before an election for representation, those who were complicit in this are aiding in the distance created. If you don’t want to have the candidates take questions, which might show how well each can think on his or her feet, then don’t allow any questions to be asked at all.. but don’t censor the content. That’s the wrong thing to do and I seriously hope that next time there’s an event like this it is taken more seriously and done differently.

Permalink Tags:          
     Views: 2216 
Latest Blog Post by salon -Turk v SCHD and Ray Reynolds Case Set for December 18 2017
More Posts You Might Enjoy
Glen Rose ISD- Tests For Thee But Not For Me (May 2013)
Your Tax Money at work at GRISD- 2 free periods but still home at 10:40 am
Banned or Restricted Books at Glen Rose ISD (Sept 2010)
Check Register for Glen Rose ISD for March 2010

 You! Leave a Comment! You Know you Want To!
You must be a registered member to comment on the blog.
Your first post is held pending approval to make sure you're not a spammer bot

 Not registered? Or you can login!

LOGON - Name:Password:

New poster comments are moderated, meaning they won't show up until approved... or not.  Be patient-we have lives outside this blog, so it might take awhile You want to be rude? totally stupid? inappropriate? Racist? Bigoted? Flame war baiter? Your post may be deleted. Spammers or people posting pretend interest comments but really wanting to hawk their latest book or sell stuff or govt propaganda flacks won't see their posts published. Comments do not necessarily reflect the viewpoint of the site owner(salon).
If you have a problem with logging in or registering, please speak up right away. Love your comments. Oh, except spammers
More on commenting



Click Here for Main Page

Latest Posts

Turk v SCHD and Ray Reynolds Case Set for December 18 2017
salon 6/21/2017

FINALLY the video from Somervell County Hospital District meeting posted (July 2017)
salon 6/21/2017

Happy Summer Solstice Day.. and other summer fun
salon 6/20/2017

Sid Miller Fined by Texas Ethics Commission
salon 6/18/2017

Summer Ahead- Light Posting (2017)
salon 6/14/2017

9th Circuit Refuses To Lift Hold on Trump's Travel Ban (June 12 2017)
salon 6/12/2017




Comments

salon > Update on letter grading from Texas Lege May 2017 In the compromise version of the bill, schools and districts would be graded in three categories: student achievement, student progress and closi.... (Letter Grades in 2017 for Glen Rose ISD and Brazos River Charter Schools)

salon > 4/3/2017-Update on the American Humanist Assoc vs Birdville ISD case. In March 2017 - A federal appeals court on Monday said a Texas school board may open its meetings with student-led prayers with.... (Religious News and Notes from the Distaff Side - 5/14/2016)

salon > Incidentally, nobody ran against Hankins, so sad to say there will be election this year.  (Updated for 2017Why I Will Not Vote for Ron Hankins, if he runs, to be on the Somervell County Hospital Board (prev 2015))

salon > Adding a great article from Texas Tribune "In courthouse turf war, Texas counties rally against statewide court records portal". The Texas Supreme Court, through its Office of Court Adm.... (Regarding Re:SearchTX and Somervell County (Glen Rose))













Home | Blog Home | About | News | Piazza | Calendar | Audio/Video/Open Rec | Search
Write!  |profile | quotes |
top Daily | top Weekly |top Month | top Year | Top All! | archives | subscribe RSS